What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear (How to Find Your Perfect Shade)

eye makeup of a woman - What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear
eye makeup of a woman - What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear
eye makeup of a woman - What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear

Dante Kim

June 19th, 2024

Get your color analysis done
in 60 seconds with WhatColors!

Get your color analysis done in
60 seconds with WhatColors!

Get your color analysis done in 60 seconds with WhatColors!

Exploring the best eyeliners for your unique eye color isn't just about aesthetics and finding shades that complement your complexion and enhance your natural beauty. Have you ever wondered how to find colors that suit you? If so, keep reading to unlock advice on selecting the perfect eyeliner hue that suits you best. Whether you're a makeup novice or a seasoned pro, finding the ideal color to define your eyes can enhance your overall look and make your eye makeup pop.

Are you ready to discover your perfect eyeliner shade that truly complements your eyes and complexion? Whatcolors' solution, unlock your colors and transform your style, is the ideal tool to assist you in achieving this goal. This valuable resource will guide you through identifying the most suitable eyeliner colors for your unique features, ensuring that your makeup routine flawlessly accentuates your natural beauty.

Table of Contents



What Are The Different Types of Eyeliner?


makeup kit for eyes - What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear


Pencil Eyeliner


Pencil eyeliner is a versatile and user-friendly option for beginners. It creates a softer, more diffused line and is perfect for tightlining or creating a smoky eye. The wide range of colors and finishes, from matte to shimmery, make pencil eyeliner ideal for various looks. Pencil eyeliners are easily smudged for a more relaxed appearance, but they tend to smudge or fade throughout the day, making them less suitable for long wear.

Gel Eyeliner


Gel eyeliner offers a happy medium between pencil and liquid options. It has a creamy consistency, allows for precise application, and offers a more intense color payoff than a pencil. Gel eyeliners come in pots or pencils and require an angled eyeliner brush for application. They are excellent for creating thin, sharp lines and dramatic winged liner looks. Gel eyeliners provide better smudging control than pencils, allowing you to create a softer look or a defined line. They are more long-lasting than pencil eyeliners.

Liquid Eyeliner


Liquid eyeliner provides the most precise application and the highest level of drama. It comes in a fine-tipped applicator, often a felt tip or brush tip. Liquid eyeliner requires a steady hand and some practice, but it allows creating sharp, defined lines and dramatic winged liner effects. Since it dries quickly, liquid eyeliner isn't ideal for smudging. Some brands offer waterproof formulas that are smudge-proof and long-lasting.

Related Reading


How To Know What Colors Look Good On You
What Color Lipstick Should I Wear
What Colors Look Good On Pale Skin
What Color Blush Should I Wear
Colors That Go With Tan
What Color Jewelry Should I Wear

Finding Your Perfect Eyeliner Shade


different shades of makeup - What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear


Brown Eyes


Brown eyes are incredibly versatile, with options ranging from classic black and brown to bolder shades like green, blue, or purple.

Hazel Eyes


Hazel eyes have a unique combination of green, gold, and brown. Enhance the green with emerald or teal liners, or highlight the gold with brown or copper.

Blue Eyes


Blue eyes look stunning with black or brown eyeliners for definition but can also be accentuated with contrasting shades like copper, bronze, or even navy blue.

Green Eyes


Green eyes can be accentuated with similar green shades or contrasting colors like purple or plum. Brown eyeliner creates a softer look.

What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear?  (Matching Eyeliner to Your Undertone)


woman with eye makeup - What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear


Skin undertones refer to the colors that shine through your skin from underneath its surface. They can be classified into three main categories: cool, warm, and neutral. Cool undertones have hints of pink, red, or blue, while warm undertones have peach, yellow, or golden touches. If you find that your skin doesn't lean cool or warm, you may have a neutral undertone, a mix of warm and cool. These undertones can impact which eyeliner shades best complement your skin tone and overall look.

Cool undertones


Black, brown, and charcoal eyeliners are generally flattering. Consider silver or blue liners for a bolder look.

Warm undertones


Brown eyeliners with warm undertones like copper or bronze work well. Experiment with dark green or plum for a statement look.

Neutral undertones


You have the most flexibility! Experiment with a variety of colors to see what flatters you most.

Discover Your Season, Best Colors, and Nail Polish Matches


WhatColors helps you find what colors to wear based on your skin tone. Get your season based on our skin tone, thanks to our patented color match technology. Get the perfect colors based on your season. Avoid colors that are a definite no. Based on your skin, eye, and hair color, find the perfect nail colors with our WhatColors Nail Color Generator. 

Unlock your colors and transform your style for free today with WhatColors’ AI Personal Color Analysis app. Download our app for free today on the App Store or Google Play store.

Colored Eyeliner for a Playful Look


woman with colored eye liner - What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear


Colored eyeliners are no longer reserved for special occasions. They can be a fun way to add a pop of color to your makeup routine and enhance your eye color. Here are some tips for incorporating them:

Choosing Complementary Colors


Consider the color wheel to choose shades that will flatter your eye color. For example, brown eyes look great with green, blue, or purple eyeliners. Blue eyes can be accentuated with copper, bronze, or even navy blue. Green eyes can be highlighted with similar green shades or contrasting colors like purple or plum.

Subtlety is Key


If you're new to colored eyeliner, start with a subtle application. Try tightlining your upper lash line with a colored pencil or using a colored eyeliner on your lower lash line for a hint of color.

Experiment with Textures


Colored eyeliners come in various textures, from matte to shimmery. Shimmery eyeliners can add a touch of glamour, while matte finishes offer a more sophisticated look.

Putting it All Together: Choosing the Right Eyeliner for Your Desired Look


woman with a makeup artist - What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear


Natural Look


Opt for shades that closely mimic your lash line for a natural, everyday look. Black or brown eyeliners are classic choices. Apply a thin line along your upper lash line, starting from the inner corner and extending slightly outwards. You can skip the lower lash line entirely or use a light brown pencil for a subtle definition.

Dramatic Look 


Black or dark brown eyeliner with a winged liner is a go-to for a dramatic look. To create a wing, extend the liner slightly upwards and outwards from the outer corner of your eye, following the natural angle of your lower lash line. Experiment with bolder colors like blue or green for a more dramatic effect.

Smoky Eye 


A smoky eye is a timeless and sultry look. Black or brown eyeliner is essential for creating one. Start by applying a thick line along your upper lash line, smudging it upwards for a diffused effect. You can also use colored eyeliner as a base for a more dramatic, smoky eye. Apply a dark eyeshadow shade on top of the eyeliner, gradually blending it outwards.

Related Reading


What Color Should I Wear
Best Colors For Olive Skin
Best Colors For Warm Undertones
What Colors Look Good On Tan Skin
What Colors Look Best On Brown Skin
Best Colors For Cool Undertones
Best Colors For Warm Skin Tone
Best Colors for Warm Undertones
What Season Am I
What Color Looks Best on Me
What Is My Color
How to Find Your Color Palette
What's My Color Palette
What Color Season Am I

Try AI Personal Color Analysis For Free Today


WhatColors’ patented color match technology is designed to help you identify the perfect colors to wear based on your skin tone. You can determine your season by analyzing your skin, eye, and hair colors and receiving customized recommendations. This technology also identifies colors that may not flatter your complexion, ensuring you avoid fashion faux pas.

Unlocking Your Perfect Colors


The WhatColors app lets you discover your ideal nail colors through the Nail Color Generator. This feature suggests nail colors that complement your skin tone, eye color, and hair color. Incorporating these hues into your style can enhance your overall look and make you feel more confident.

Transform Your Style with WhatColors


To experience the benefits of WhatColors’ AI Personal Color Analysis app firsthand, download it for free on the App Store or Google Play store. You can revitalize your wardrobe and elevate your style to new heights by unlocking your perfect colors. 

Let WhatColors help you express your personality through your fashion choices and make a lasting impression wherever you go.

Related Reading


Best Colors for Medium Skin Tone
What Colors Look Good on Pale Skin with Pink Undertones
What Does It Mean When a Color Washes You Out
Best Colors for Light Brown Skin
What Color Prom Dress Should I Wear
What Color Eyeshadow Should I Wear
Best Colors for Light Skin
Best Colors for Yellow Undertones
Best Clothing Colors for Fair Skin
Best Clothing Colors for Pale Skin Male
Best Colors for Winter Skin Tone

Get your color analysis done
in 60 seconds with WhatColors!

Exploring the best eyeliners for your unique eye color isn't just about aesthetics and finding shades that complement your complexion and enhance your natural beauty. Have you ever wondered how to find colors that suit you? If so, keep reading to unlock advice on selecting the perfect eyeliner hue that suits you best. Whether you're a makeup novice or a seasoned pro, finding the ideal color to define your eyes can enhance your overall look and make your eye makeup pop.

Are you ready to discover your perfect eyeliner shade that truly complements your eyes and complexion? Whatcolors' solution, unlock your colors and transform your style, is the ideal tool to assist you in achieving this goal. This valuable resource will guide you through identifying the most suitable eyeliner colors for your unique features, ensuring that your makeup routine flawlessly accentuates your natural beauty.

Table of Contents



What Are The Different Types of Eyeliner?


makeup kit for eyes - What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear


Pencil Eyeliner


Pencil eyeliner is a versatile and user-friendly option for beginners. It creates a softer, more diffused line and is perfect for tightlining or creating a smoky eye. The wide range of colors and finishes, from matte to shimmery, make pencil eyeliner ideal for various looks. Pencil eyeliners are easily smudged for a more relaxed appearance, but they tend to smudge or fade throughout the day, making them less suitable for long wear.

Gel Eyeliner


Gel eyeliner offers a happy medium between pencil and liquid options. It has a creamy consistency, allows for precise application, and offers a more intense color payoff than a pencil. Gel eyeliners come in pots or pencils and require an angled eyeliner brush for application. They are excellent for creating thin, sharp lines and dramatic winged liner looks. Gel eyeliners provide better smudging control than pencils, allowing you to create a softer look or a defined line. They are more long-lasting than pencil eyeliners.

Liquid Eyeliner


Liquid eyeliner provides the most precise application and the highest level of drama. It comes in a fine-tipped applicator, often a felt tip or brush tip. Liquid eyeliner requires a steady hand and some practice, but it allows creating sharp, defined lines and dramatic winged liner effects. Since it dries quickly, liquid eyeliner isn't ideal for smudging. Some brands offer waterproof formulas that are smudge-proof and long-lasting.

Related Reading


How To Know What Colors Look Good On You
What Color Lipstick Should I Wear
What Colors Look Good On Pale Skin
What Color Blush Should I Wear
Colors That Go With Tan
What Color Jewelry Should I Wear

Finding Your Perfect Eyeliner Shade


different shades of makeup - What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear


Brown Eyes


Brown eyes are incredibly versatile, with options ranging from classic black and brown to bolder shades like green, blue, or purple.

Hazel Eyes


Hazel eyes have a unique combination of green, gold, and brown. Enhance the green with emerald or teal liners, or highlight the gold with brown or copper.

Blue Eyes


Blue eyes look stunning with black or brown eyeliners for definition but can also be accentuated with contrasting shades like copper, bronze, or even navy blue.

Green Eyes


Green eyes can be accentuated with similar green shades or contrasting colors like purple or plum. Brown eyeliner creates a softer look.

What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear?  (Matching Eyeliner to Your Undertone)


woman with eye makeup - What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear


Skin undertones refer to the colors that shine through your skin from underneath its surface. They can be classified into three main categories: cool, warm, and neutral. Cool undertones have hints of pink, red, or blue, while warm undertones have peach, yellow, or golden touches. If you find that your skin doesn't lean cool or warm, you may have a neutral undertone, a mix of warm and cool. These undertones can impact which eyeliner shades best complement your skin tone and overall look.

Cool undertones


Black, brown, and charcoal eyeliners are generally flattering. Consider silver or blue liners for a bolder look.

Warm undertones


Brown eyeliners with warm undertones like copper or bronze work well. Experiment with dark green or plum for a statement look.

Neutral undertones


You have the most flexibility! Experiment with a variety of colors to see what flatters you most.

Discover Your Season, Best Colors, and Nail Polish Matches


WhatColors helps you find what colors to wear based on your skin tone. Get your season based on our skin tone, thanks to our patented color match technology. Get the perfect colors based on your season. Avoid colors that are a definite no. Based on your skin, eye, and hair color, find the perfect nail colors with our WhatColors Nail Color Generator. 

Unlock your colors and transform your style for free today with WhatColors’ AI Personal Color Analysis app. Download our app for free today on the App Store or Google Play store.

Colored Eyeliner for a Playful Look


woman with colored eye liner - What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear


Colored eyeliners are no longer reserved for special occasions. They can be a fun way to add a pop of color to your makeup routine and enhance your eye color. Here are some tips for incorporating them:

Choosing Complementary Colors


Consider the color wheel to choose shades that will flatter your eye color. For example, brown eyes look great with green, blue, or purple eyeliners. Blue eyes can be accentuated with copper, bronze, or even navy blue. Green eyes can be highlighted with similar green shades or contrasting colors like purple or plum.

Subtlety is Key


If you're new to colored eyeliner, start with a subtle application. Try tightlining your upper lash line with a colored pencil or using a colored eyeliner on your lower lash line for a hint of color.

Experiment with Textures


Colored eyeliners come in various textures, from matte to shimmery. Shimmery eyeliners can add a touch of glamour, while matte finishes offer a more sophisticated look.

Putting it All Together: Choosing the Right Eyeliner for Your Desired Look


woman with a makeup artist - What Color Eyeliner Should I Wear


Natural Look


Opt for shades that closely mimic your lash line for a natural, everyday look. Black or brown eyeliners are classic choices. Apply a thin line along your upper lash line, starting from the inner corner and extending slightly outwards. You can skip the lower lash line entirely or use a light brown pencil for a subtle definition.

Dramatic Look 


Black or dark brown eyeliner with a winged liner is a go-to for a dramatic look. To create a wing, extend the liner slightly upwards and outwards from the outer corner of your eye, following the natural angle of your lower lash line. Experiment with bolder colors like blue or green for a more dramatic effect.

Smoky Eye 


A smoky eye is a timeless and sultry look. Black or brown eyeliner is essential for creating one. Start by applying a thick line along your upper lash line, smudging it upwards for a diffused effect. You can also use colored eyeliner as a base for a more dramatic, smoky eye. Apply a dark eyeshadow shade on top of the eyeliner, gradually blending it outwards.

Related Reading


What Color Should I Wear
Best Colors For Olive Skin
Best Colors For Warm Undertones
What Colors Look Good On Tan Skin
What Colors Look Best On Brown Skin
Best Colors For Cool Undertones
Best Colors For Warm Skin Tone
Best Colors for Warm Undertones
What Season Am I
What Color Looks Best on Me
What Is My Color
How to Find Your Color Palette
What's My Color Palette
What Color Season Am I

Try AI Personal Color Analysis For Free Today


WhatColors’ patented color match technology is designed to help you identify the perfect colors to wear based on your skin tone. You can determine your season by analyzing your skin, eye, and hair colors and receiving customized recommendations. This technology also identifies colors that may not flatter your complexion, ensuring you avoid fashion faux pas.

Unlocking Your Perfect Colors


The WhatColors app lets you discover your ideal nail colors through the Nail Color Generator. This feature suggests nail colors that complement your skin tone, eye color, and hair color. Incorporating these hues into your style can enhance your overall look and make you feel more confident.

Transform Your Style with WhatColors


To experience the benefits of WhatColors’ AI Personal Color Analysis app firsthand, download it for free on the App Store or Google Play store. You can revitalize your wardrobe and elevate your style to new heights by unlocking your perfect colors. 

Let WhatColors help you express your personality through your fashion choices and make a lasting impression wherever you go.

Related Reading


Best Colors for Medium Skin Tone
What Colors Look Good on Pale Skin with Pink Undertones
What Does It Mean When a Color Washes You Out
Best Colors for Light Brown Skin
What Color Prom Dress Should I Wear
What Color Eyeshadow Should I Wear
Best Colors for Light Skin
Best Colors for Yellow Undertones
Best Clothing Colors for Fair Skin
Best Clothing Colors for Pale Skin Male
Best Colors for Winter Skin Tone

Unlock Your Colors,
Transform Your Style

Get your color analysis done in 60 seconds!